Yogurt Making: 5 Best Kits for Creamy Results at Home
The Story of Yogurt Making at Home
When I first started with yogurt making, it was all trial and error. A saucepan here, a tea towel there,a big mess on the kitchen counter and plenty of crossed fingers and naughty words. Some mornings I woke to perfect jars of creamy tang. Other times… let’s just say the pig and chickens ended up with runny milk.
That’s when I realized: the right kit makes all the difference. Whether you want grab-and-go jars, Greek-style thickness, or a modern digital setup that handles temperature for you, there are plenty of options. But not all yogurt making kits are created equal.
Affiliate Disclosure: This post contains Amazon affiliate links. If you purchase through them, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Here are five I’d recommend—each with its own character, pros, and quirks—depending on what kind of yogurt maker you want to be.
1. Euro Cuisine YM80 – The Family Classic
There’s something comforting about this one. The Euro Cuisine YM80 has been around for years, and for good reason. It comes with seven small glass jars, each with a lid. That means you can set up a batch with multiple flavors at once—plain for cooking, vanilla for parfaits, strawberry for the kids.
Pros:
- Individual jars make portioning and experimenting fun.
- Reliable temperature control.
- Glass jars = easy to clean, reusable forever.
Cons:
- You still need to heat the milk separately on the stovetop before incubating.
- Small jars mean you may need two batches a week for a big family.
2. Euro Cuisine GY60 – For Greek Yogurt Lovers
If you’ve ever tried to strain yogurt through cheesecloth, you’ll know the mess it leaves. The Euro Cuisine GY60 solves that problem beautifully. It’s essentially a Greek yogurt strainer: a stainless steel mesh basket that sits inside a sturdy container. You pour in regular yogurt, and a few hours later you have thick, creamy Greek yogurt—no drips, no waste.
Pros:
- Large capacity (about 2 quarts).
- Stainless steel mesh = durable and easy to clean.
- Produces café-style thick yogurt without fuss.
Cons:
- Not a full yogurt maker—it only strains. You still need to ferment your yogurt first in another kit (or even in the YM80).
- Takes up fridge space while straining.
3. Digital Greek Yogurt Maker Machine – The Modern Option
For those who love tech in the kitchen, a Digital Greek Yogurt Maker Machine is like having a sous-chef. These machines usually come with a digital display, timer, and multiple jars or a large tub. You set the time, close the lid, and the machine holds the perfect temperature until your yogurt is ready.
Pros:
- Foolproof incubation with precise digital control.
- Many include jars and Greek strainer inserts.
- Great for busy families—set and forget.
Cons:
- Bulkier than simpler kits.
- Slightly higher price point than basic models.
4. EasiYo Starter Kit – The Beginner’s Best Friend
Sometimes you just want yogurt making to be quick and foolproof. The EasiYo Starter Kit delivers exactly that. It comes with a container, an insulated sleeve, and sachets of yogurt mix. You just add water, mix, tuck the jar in with hot water, and wait.
Pros:
- Almost no learning curve.
- Sachets are convenient, consistent, and kid-friendly.
- Perfect for families who want yogurt without fuss.
Cons:
- Less control over ingredients—limited to sachet flavors.
- Doesn’t make Greek-style yogurt without extra straining.
5. Bear Yogurt Maker – Stylish & Versatile
The Bear Yogurt Maker is one of those Amazon finds that surprises you. Sleek design, multiple glass jars, and a digital timer—it feels like the halfway point between the old-school YM80 and the modern Greek yogurt machines. It’s also versatile: some models even let you make rice wine or kefir.
Pros:
- Stylish design with clear digital controls.
- Multiple jars for variety.
- Often doubles as a fermenter for other foods.
Cons:
- Brand is newer compared to Euro Cuisine, so long-term durability varies.
- Some users say instructions could be clearer.
Which Yogurt Making Kit Should You Choose?
- For families who want variety and portion control: Euro Cuisine YM80.
- For Greek yogurt lovers who already make regular yogurt: Euro Cuisine GY60.
- For tech lovers who want set-and-forget convenience: Digital Greek Yogurt Maker Machine.
- For beginners who want zero stress: EasiYo Starter Kit.
- For style and versatility: Bear Yogurt Maker.
Final Thoughts
In the end, yogurt making is more than just a kitchen project. It’s a ritual, a way of slowing down and creating something nourishing from scratch. The right kit doesn’t just save you time—it keeps the process joyful instead of stressful.
Whether you’re spooning strawberry yogurt into school lunch jars, straining a rich Greek batch for dinner dips, or just trying your very first sachet, each of these yogurt making kits has a story to tell. The only question is: which one fits your kitchen story best?